clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Brian McCann could get nine figures

New, comments

McCann is a "top-five" catcher in baseball and he's set to hit the market this winter, but is he worth $100MM?

Kevin C. Cox

An anonymous MLB GM told ESPN New York's Andrew Marchand that he thinks Atlanta Braves catcher and Fun Police Commissioner Brian McCann could land a $100MM deal in free agency this offseason. The GM hypothesizes a 6-year $100MM deal as a possibility within the realm of well, possibility.

Marchand goes on to mention Joe Mauer's 8-year $184MM pact with Minnesota and Yadier Molina's 5-year $75MM deal with the Cardinals as reference points. McCann is just 29 years-old and has managed 20 home runs or more in 7 of his 8 full seasons in Atlanta.

Expect most of the interest to come from the AL, as it would be easier to absorb McCann's physical decline with a non-fielding spot in the order.

The Yankees are Marchand's primary focus in the article, and they make a lot of sense as a new home for McCann -- especially if Alex Rodriguez' suspension holds up and the team allows Robinson Cano to sign elsewhere.

More Braves CoverageTalking Chop More on the Yanks: Pinstriped Bible

The GM called McCann a "top-five catcher" and it's hard to argue with that assessment -- unless you use advanced metrics. McCann ranks 16th in fWAR over the last two years (minimum of 750 plate appearances). His wRC+ of 103 over that span ranks 15th, just below the A.J. couplet of Pierzynski and Ellis. Doesn't sound like a $100MM man, does it?

McCann's leadership will probably be harped on often in the coverage of his potential destinations, but it's difficult to put a number on something like clubhouse presence. And for those of you that think he might be kind of a bummer to ice your wounds with, go watch the most recent Fun Police play again. He's just backing up his teammates. Of course, he had a history of similar outbursts before the Gomez incident.

Despite enviable alternatives, the Braves may decide to keep their long-time catcher around. Evan Gattis can hit, sure, but he isn't a viable option behind the plate, or really anywhere on the field outside the batter's box. Atlanta also has a strong catching prospect in Christian Bethancourt, but he has 3,862 fewer MLB at bats than McCann -- in other words, one. They could use the young backstop as chip on the trade market and re-sign McCann if they decide his leadership -- and more importantly, his on-field contributions -- are worth $100MM.

McCann may leave. And he may very well sign with the Yankees as Marchand proposes, but it seems pretty obvious...

The Braves LOVE Brian McCann.

Braves1bof

More from MLB Daily Dish: